Fantastic Beasts Fails By Ignoring What Made Harry Potter So Great

The Fantastic Beasts films seem to be to expand the Wizarding World, but that creates a problem in overlooking what made Harry Potter so special.

Fantastic Beasts Fails By Ignoring What Made Harry Potter So Great

 

The Fantastic Beasts films seem to be to expand the Wizarding World, but that creates a problem in overlooking what made Harry Potter so special.

 

 

One of the key reasons the Fantastic Beasts films have failed is that they pass a massive section of what made Harry Potter so exquisite and beloved. Warner Bros. had ambitious plans for the Fantastic Beasts franchise, with five films in whole predicted to inform the story now not only of magizoologist Newt Scamander (Eddie Redmayne), but additionally increase the Wizarding World and reveal the fact in the back of the rise of Gellert Grindelwald (formerly performed by way of Johnny Depp, now Mads Mikkelsen). Unfortunately for the studio, matters have never absolutely acquired going for the series.

 

 

The first movie, Fantastic Beasts And Where To Find Them, used to be a solid sufficient success, with in most cases fantastic evaluations and a box workplace haul of $814 million, which was once first rate even within the Harry Potter franchise. The broader issues ostensibly commenced in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes Of Grindelwald, which was once criticized with the aid of movie critics and audiences alike and underperformed at the box office, making $654 million. There are myriad problems with Fantastic Beasts each behind-the-scenes and in phrases of its method to storytelling, however one of the largest is a essential difficulty with the Wizarding World itself.

 

 

To various degrees, all of the Fantastic Beasts movies, which includes Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore, appear to expand upon the Wizarding World, going to new areas and making big exhibits and additions to the lore. Aside from Fantastic Beasts movies developing Harry Potter plot holes, this strategy to world building also ignores plenty of what made Harry Potter sense so distinctive to commence with: Hogwarts. The movies have touched upon the School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, most enormously with the presence of a youthful Albus Dumbledore (Jude Law), however it's never been the principal focus due to its titular storylines, and that explains in section why the franchise would not work as properly as the Harry Potter movies.

 

 

It was Hogwarts that was once key to making Harry Potter work. It was that region that so perfectly captured the series' innate sense of magic, both in the books and brilliantly introduced to lifestyles in the films (which weren't flawless, however did a exquisite job of shooting the wonder of the faculty and flawlessly cast Hogwarts' professors). It's in Hogwarts that Harry Potter offers the experience of escapism and acceptance that made it work its way into the hearts and minds of so many; where it brilliantly blended truth with delusion to conjure up a fully-realized sense of area for readers and viewers to dream of going to. Fantastic Beasts is extra of a globe-trotting adventure, which in turn means there may be nothing to supply it that equal extraordinary feeling of place or to find that belonging.

 

This is in section an trouble with even attempting to enlarge the Wizarding World, due to the fact unlike, say, Middle-earth or Westeros, the genius didn't lie in an expansive, richly special map full of one of a kind locations, but alternatively largely on a singular location that tapped into the pleasure of imagination, wish-fulfilment, and the childhood marvel that possibly this ought to actually exist. The Harry Potter books and movies themselves went beyond Hogwarts with some splendid locations - Hogsmeade, Diagon Alley, the Burrow, to name however a few - however crucially they all, for the most part, served its Hogwarts-centric story in some way, be it a stop-gap on the way there or a quick pause amidst the term. They felt distinct because, in a way, they had been an growth of what made the faculty work, fitting into its core subject matters of friendship, household (biological and found), and acceptance.

 

The Fantastic Beasts films tried to be higher than Hogwarts, and thinking they should gain that by going to greater places and introducing a new raft of characters, before rapidly adjusting route to healthy extra carefully to Harry Potter's story - in unique Dumbledore and Grindelwald - but besides re-capturing what made people love it to begin with and in no way truly being in a position to compete. Harry Potter itself gave recommendations of the larger Wizarding World that labored nicely - the Quidditch World Cup, and the presence of Beauxbatons and Durmstrang, all inside the same book/movie - but they were continually an addition to Hogwarts, by no means detracting from it. Of course, Hogwarts used to be Harry Potter's genuine home, which gave it an advantage over Fantastic Beasts' characters, but the likes of Newt and Dumbledore have obvious, deep ties to the faculty that it pull on more to try and remember what made the series it spins off from so good.

 

 


Harriet Angela

4464 Blog posts

Comments